Delegates to Michigan Convention to Ratify
21st Amendment
Election held April 3, 1933
Convention held April 10, 1933
The 21st Amendment to the U.S. Constitution repealed the 18th Amendment
(Prohibition). It was the only constitutional amendment in history which
Congress specified had to be ratified by state conventions rather than by
state legislatures.
Michigan acted quickly in order to get the issue before voters at the
spring election. A bill was adopted to provide for a convention with 100
delegates, one for each state rep seat. Unlike the 1961 constitutional
convention, no delegates were elected from state senate districts.
For each delegate position, there were two candidates: one pledged to
vote "yes" on ratifying the amendment (the so-called "wet" candidate), the
other pledged to vote "no" (the "dry" candidate).
The candidates were selected by county election commissions in each
county (i.e., the county clerk, the county treasurer, and the chief
probate judge), and were typically leaders of organizations campaigning to
repeal or to maintain alcohol prohibition. In several counties, the names
first announced were changed by the time ballots were printed.
Many newspapers pointed out that the convention had no deliberative
function, and advised voters to vote their views on Prohibition rather
than partisanship or personalities.
On April 3, 1933, Michigan voters elected 99 "wet" delegates and just
one "dry" delegate (from Barry County).
The convention was held one week later in Lansing, and voted 99-1 for
ratification of the repeal amendment. Michigan was the first state to
ratify.
Two delegates, Charles E. Bartlett and Emil J. DeBacke (marked with *
in the list below), both of the Wayne 1st, were unable to attend; Gov.
William A. Comstock appointed substitutes for them. For Bartlett's
position, Robert J. Teagan was appointed; for DeBacke's position, his
brother Victor DeBacke was appointed.
Art Jensen (Montcalm County) was absent on the initial roll call, but
he arrived in time for the ratification vote.
These events are somewhat obscure, perhaps because the election of
delegates and convention were not documented in the 1933 Michigan
Manual. The original records were destroyed in the 1951 state
archives fire. Information on this page was compiled from state and
county records and from newspaper reports by Lawrence Kestenbaum,
2007.
All of these delegates and candidates will soon be included in the Political Graveyard web site.
If you are willing to share any biographical
information on any of these individuals (e.g., birth and death dates,
occupation, hometown, religious affiliation, etc.), please contact me via
email at POLYGON at POLITICALGRAVEYARD
dot COM, or by postal mail to Lawrence Kestenbaum, P.O.
Box 2563, Ann Arbor MI 48106.
District |
Winning candidate |
Losing candidate |
Alger District |
L. B. Chittenden (wet) |
George A. Baldwin (dry) |
Allegan County |
Raymond L. Anglemire (wet) |
Floyd M. Barden (dry) |
Alpena District |
Arthur W. Wilcox (wet) |
Joseph H. Thompson (dry) |
Antrim District |
Guy H. Kane (wet) |
E. S. Carroll (dry) |
Arenac District |
Herman N. Butler (wet) |
Annie E. Parliament (dry) |
Barry County |
Eugene Davenport (dry) |
Birge C. Swift (wet) |
Bay County 1st District |
Adolph J. Rehmus (wet) |
Archibald H. McMillan (dry) |
Bay County 2nd District |
Samuel H. Castanier (wet) |
Carl M. Cook (dry) |
Berrien County 1st District |
Julius J. Krieger (wet) |
Emma Jean Hall (dry) |
Berrien County 2nd District |
Doris C. Hawks (wet) |
Harris S. Whitney (dry) |
Branch County |
Mortimer W. Olds (wet) |
Delbert E. Williams (dry) |
Calhoun County 1st District |
Charles E. Gauss (wet) |
Frederic S. Goodrich (dry) |
Calhoun County 2nd District |
Howard W. Cavanagh (wet) |
Verner W. Main (dry) |
Cass County |
Carl B. Dill (wet) |
William H. Berkey (dry) |
Charlevoix District |
Thomas C. Kroupa (wet) |
Henry Steimel (dry) |
Cheboygan District |
John C. Rittenhouse (wet) |
Allen Schreur (dry) |
Chippewa County |
Robert S. Moore (wet) |
Marshall W. Hoyt (dry) |
Clinton County |
Herbert Armbrustmacher (wet) |
A. M. Pearl (dry) |
Delta County |
Cornelius Gallagher (wet) |
Charles N. Wood (dry) |
Dickinson County |
Earl M. LaFreniere (wet) |
Edwin Asp (dry) |
Eaton County |
Albert M. Ewert (wet) |
Stanley B. Niles (dry) |
Emmet District |
John B. Vallier (wet) |
George A. Weaver (dry) |
Genesee County 1st District |
Carl Bonbright (wet)
James Martin (wet) |
Alvin N. Cody (dry)
Mary Blackwell (dry) |
Genesee County 2nd District |
Frank J. Sawyer (wet) |
Alfred Stevens (dry) |
Gogebic County |
Thomas J. Landers (wet) |
John Kuivinen (dry) |
Grand Traverse County |
Timothy R. Temple (wet) |
Demas Cochlin (dry) |
Gratiot County |
Edwin Raynor (wet) |
Leon L. Tyler (dry) |
Hillsdale County |
George D. Schermerhorn (wet) |
James Denver Driskill (dry) |
Houghton County 1st District |
William L. Stannard (wet) |
Samuel A. Carey (dry) |
Houghton County 2nd District |
James T. Healy (wet) |
Matt M. Dennis (dry) |
Huron County |
William J. Riley (wet) |
Charlotte Allison (dry) |
Ingham County 1st District |
Homer D. Parker (wet) |
Glenn M. Frye (dry) |
Ingham County 2nd District |
William J. Barber (wet) |
Dora H. Stockman (dry) |
Ionia County |
Fred A. Chapman (wet) |
George L. Jordan (dry) |
Iron County |
Martin S. McDonough (wet) |
Carl A. Rosander (dry) |
Isabella County |
Thomas R. McNamara (wet) |
Floyd H. Johnson (dry) |
Jackson County 1st District |
John W. Miner (wet) |
Earle J. Engle (dry) |
Jackson County 2nd District |
Dean G. Kimball (wet) |
Mark B. Hawes (dry) |
Kalamazoo County 1st District |
Dean Halford (wet) |
James B. Balch (dry) |
Kalamazoo County 2nd District |
William Montague (wet) |
Samuel H. Van Horn (dry) |
Kent County 1st District |
Charles R. Bowman (wet)
Dorothy S. McAllister (wet)
John J. Smolenski (wet) |
Frank A. Bacon (dry)
Henry Beets (dry)
Fred P. Geib (dry) |
Kent County 2nd District |
John M. Dunham (wet) |
J. Pomeroy Munson (dry) |
Kent County 3rd District |
William S. Lamoreaux (wet) |
M. Harold Saur (dry) |
Lapeer County |
Loren H. Richards (wet) |
Fred J. Stephenson (dry) |
Lenawee County |
Bert D. Chandler (wet) |
Eugene P. Lake (dry) |
Livingston County |
Bert Pate (wet) |
William H. Caulfield (dry) |
Macomb County |
Austin W. Heine (wet) |
Emerson O. Gildart (dry) |
Manistee County |
William D. Manchester (wet) |
Luke Keddie (dry) |
Marquette County |
Connor Cowpland (wet) |
S. S. Stockwell (dry) |
Mason County |
Fred J. Hermann (wet) |
B. S. Bailey (dry) |
Mecosta District |
Arnold C. Misteli (wet) |
Walter F. Jackson (dry) |
Menominee County |
Hugh Bresnahan (wet) |
William Lovejoy (dry) |
Midland District |
Frank I. Wixom (wet) |
Neil C. McKay (dry) |
Monroe County |
Henry F. R. Frincke (wet) |
Elroy M. Loose (dry) |
Montcalm County |
Art Jensen (wet) |
Leo B. Niles (dry) |
Muskegon County 1st District |
Fred J. Loewe (wet) |
Wesley E. Dyer (dry) |
Muskegon County 2nd District |
Elliott D. Prescott (wet) |
Vincent A. Martin (dry) |
Newaygo District |
Robert W. Mason (wet) |
Lester Wilcox (dry) |
Oakland County 1st District |
Preston C. Allen (wet) |
Ralph I. Coryell (dry) |
Oakland County 2nd District |
Clarence W. Seery (wet) |
Sadie M. Patten (dry) |
Ontonagon District |
Edwin J. Evans (wet) |
August Wallen (dry) |
Osceola District |
Floyd Doherty (wet) |
Leah Garchow (dry) |
Ottawa County |
William A. Hanrahan (wet) |
Wynand Wichers (dry) |
Presque Isle District |
Edward A. Westrope (wet) |
Norman J. Randall (dry) |
Saginaw County 1st District |
Albert S. Harvey (wet)
Frank A. Picard (wet) |
Fred M. Bullock (dry)
William R. Longstreet (dry) |
Saginaw County 2nd District |
Otto J. Conzelmann (wet) |
Cora Chilton (dry) |
St. Clair County 1st District |
Charlotte H. McMorran (wet) |
De Hull Black (dry) |
St. Clair County 2nd District |
John H. Schlinkert (wet) |
Jean Herbert (dry) |
St. Joseph County |
Dan J. Gerow (wet) |
Eugene Rider (dry) |
Sanilac County |
Robert A. Turrel (wet) |
Oscar F. Buschlen (dry) |
Shiawassee County |
William J. McCullough (wet) |
Ellis F. Wilson (dry) |
Tuscola County |
Wilbert H. Cook (wet) |
Arthur D. Gallery (dry) |
Van Buren County |
Cecil A. Runyan (wet) |
David Anderson (dry) |
Washtenaw County |
Nathan S. Potter (wet) |
Lewis C. Reimann (dry) |
Wayne County 1st District |
Mary E. Alger (wet)
Robert H. Clancy (wet)
*Charles E. Bartlett (wet)
Robert D. Wardell (wet)
Arthur J. Lacy (wet)
Andrew C. Baird (wet)
Helen R. Dean (wet)
Sidney T. Miller (wet)
William F. Dettling (wet)
Catherine D. Doran (wet)
Frank D. Eaman (wet)
Charles A. Roxborough (wet)
Rex Humphrey (wet)
Roscoe B. Huston (wet)
John W. Woznak (wet)
George A. Ott (wet)
*Emil J. DeBacke (wet)
|
Charles E. Clark (dry)
Ben A. Baldwin (dry)
Douglas A. Graham (dry)
Merton S. Rice (dry)
Margaret V. Field (dry)
Charles F. Kuhn (dry)
Lincoln E. Buell (dry)
Ernest S. Marks (dry)
Arthur F. Tull (dry)
Etta B. Saunders (dry)
Henry C. Gleiss (dry)
J. Henry Ling (dry)
E. Elmer Staub (dry)
Thomas L. Starnes (dry)
Edward E. Maten (dry)
Ava Downer (dry)
Anna Surline (dry) |
Wayne County 2nd District |
Clyde Austin (wet) |
George R. Malone (dry) |
Wayne County 3rd District |
Stephen S. Skrzycki (wet) |
Albert A. Ziarko (dry) |
Wayne County 4th District |
Robert M. Ashley (wet) |
Charles A. Brethen (dry) |
Wayne County 5th District |
Elton R. Eaton (wet) |
Evered V. Joffiffe (dry) |
Wexford District |
Lundy J. Deming (wet) |
William L. Case (dry) |
|